Sarah and Caroline’s friendship began on the Massachusetts coast, during their childhood summers on Nantucket. As they grew up, the two found themselves yearning for those simple, carefree days by the sea. With an unquenchable passion for all things sweet, Sarah and Caroline created Tuck Shop after their favorite little chocolate shop closed on the island. These chocolates not only tantalize the taste buds but also celebrate beloved destinations through packaging that captures each place’s charm. Tuck Shop proves that chocolate isn’t just dessert—it’s a gateway to relive moments that have shaped who we are. The OTM Exclusive: Set of Personalized New York Milk Chocolate Bars will transport you—and whoever you share them with—to your own happy place.

Product Details

40% cacao. Sugar, cocoa butter, soy lecithin, and vanilla.

Care Instructions

Keep in a cool, dry place.  

Size & Fit

6" L x 3" W x 0.5" H

Shipping Details

Please allow 3-4 weeks for personalization and 5-7 days for standard delivery.

Return Policy

This item is final sale and not available for return.